NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPEpic Wear Liquid Liner, Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner - Black

I put this eyeliner on this morning. I cried 5 times, applied sunscreen and played soccer for 2 hours, even took 2 showers and it has not BUDGED. Exactly what I have been looking for!

I give this a 10/10!! I wanted an eyeliner that doesn’t wear off and I finely found it. You need to apply this on dry skin. If you have any eye cream or lotion on it will transfer and wear off. Very hard to wash off. You can get it off better with coconut oil or eye makeup remover. But that’s what I wanted. I highly recommend this. I got the Brown and Brown Metal that’s like a metallic. I’ll be buying again.

This is currently my favorite eyeliner. No joke I've cried and slept in this eyeliner in the same day and it did not come off at all. Be warned it is hard to remove

This eyeliners strength is also its weakness; it does not come off easily. I’ve included pictures of just after I did my makeup and after I washed my face and used a Qtip and micellar water to scrub the middle away. I gave up after that and just left it on overnight and it looked virtually the same in the morning. My next guess is to use coconut oil to get it off but we shall see!

Doesn't flake or shed like some other white eyeliners I've had before, actual formula goes on your lids very easily, dries pretty quickly, and lasts a long time!

Best value for money. Super easy to use. Very fine tip. Dries quickly. My favorite all time eyeliner. I will purchase again.

I ordered the metallic pink.What I love about it: The color is absolutely beautiful! I was wanting something bold and metallic and this definitely fit the bill. Another pro is that it is pretty waterproof and smudgeproof which is a must for me! For some people this is a con due to it being difficult to take off. For me I don't want my eyeliner to come off so this is a very important pro and something that I specifically look for in eyeliner. So that is the good. The downside, and something I've discovered about myself in this process, I prefer the thicker and sturdier applicator tips like the H20 waterproof liquid eyeliner applicator tip. Funny enough some people dislike those applicators but those are best for me. My wings comes out perfect every time when I use that product. This applicator, which is a fairly common applicator type for liquid eyeliner, I just find very difficult and messy personally. The tip is very, very fine and flimsy, and the product is pretty watery in my opinion and not very opaque. This for me means doing multiple layers all of which looks messy because I can't get a steady hand like I can with those other applicators. All in all I wanted to like this liner so badly but I don't think I will even keep it to be honest as it was such a pain for me to apply. I can usually whip these wings on my eyes in 5 minutes but this took much longer and looked slightly messy when I was finished. I'm going to try a different applicator with the same product before throwing the product away, but the product itself was pretty thin and watery too, so I think ultimately I'll have to toss and search for something else. There were a lot of good reviews for this product but it ended up not being for me. Absolutely beautiful color, it just didn't look very nice on me due to lack of steady hand and clumping due to all of the layering I had to do. I'll give it a 3/5 because I do love the waterproof and smudgeproof part and I do love the color. Purchase at your own discretion.

Stays on for a couple of days, even after I gently wash my face!